Thank you so much to the 176 people who shared their proposal stories! I used random.org to randomize the numbers 1-176, and the winning comment is:

# 132 Mia Jacobs

We had been living together about 5 years and we had borrowed a friends convertible to drive up to Lake Tahoe. We were just taking a walk along the beach enjoying the beautiful sunset when he got on his knee and pulled out the ring. It was very romantic.

Thank you for sharing your story, Mia! Enjoy your DVDs!